Use of multi-criteria decision analysis to identify potentially dangerous glacial lakes

Kougkoulos, Ioannis, Cook, Simon J ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1532-6532, Jomelli, Vincent, Clarke, Leon ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2278-4139, Symeonakis, Ilias, Dortch, Jason M, Edwards, Laura A and Merad, Myriam (2018) Use of multi-criteria decision analysis to identify potentially dangerous glacial lakes. Science of the Total Environment, 621. pp. 1453-1466. ISSN 0048-9697

Preview

Accepted Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives. Download (933kB) | Preview

Abstract

Glacial Lake Outburst Floods (GLOFs) represent a significant threat in deglaciating environments, necessitating the development of GLOF hazard and risk assessment procedures. Here, we outline a Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) approach that can be used to rapidly identify potentially dangerous lakes in regions without existing tailored GLOF risk assessments, where a range of glacial lake types exist, and where field data are sparse or non-existent. Our MCDA model (1) is desk-based and uses freely and widely available data inputs and software, and (2) allows the relative risk posed by a range of glacial lake types to be assessed simultaneously within any region. A review of the factors that influence GLOF risk, combined with the strict rules of criteria selection inherent to MCDA, has allowed us to identify 13 exhaustive, non-redundant, and consistent risk criteria. We use our MCDA model to assess the risk of 16 extant glacial lakes and 6 lakes that have already generated GLOFs, and found that our results agree well with previous studies. For the first time in GLOF risk assessment, we employed sensitivity analyses to test the strength of our model results and assumptions, and to identify lakes that are sensitive to the criteria and risk thresholds used. A key benefit of the MCDA method is that sensitivity analyses are readily undertaken. Overall, these sensitivity analyses lend support to our model, although we suggest that further work is required to determine the relative importance of assessment criteria, and the thresholds that determine the level of risk for each criterion. As a case study, the tested method was then applied to 25 potentially dangerous lakes in the Bolivian Andes, where GLOF risk is poorly understood; 3 lakes are found to pose ‘medium’ or ‘high’ risk, and require further detailed investigation.