Using group improvisation and imaginative listening to nurture creative autonomy in A-level music students: teaching composition for examination purposes in England

Hartley, Jennie Claire (2023) Using group improvisation and imaginative listening to nurture creative autonomy in A-level music students: teaching composition for examination purposes in England. Doctoral thesis (PhD), The Royal Northern College of Music in collaboration with Manchester Metropolitan University.

Preview	Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives. Download (33MB) | Preview
	Other File not available for download. Available under License In Copyright. Download (71MB)

Abstract

This thesis examines the effects of group improvisation and imaginative listening on teaching and learning in the composing component of A-level Music in one school in England. Problems with teaching composition in schools have long been acknowledged, with the same issues raised across studies spanning several years: how to teach it, and how to interpret assessment criteria. In that context, this action research project developed in response to a perceived association between students’ behaviours in composition and listening, with cautious, teacher-reliant composers also struggling to listen constructively to music that presented new aesthetic challenges. As studies with A-level Music students are rare and there is no research connecting listening, improvising, and composing in this context, a wide range of literature, educational and otherwise, was consulted. This scholarship underpins two central studies in this project, undertaken in the academic year 2020-21. The first study aimed to enable students to participate in group improvisation, addressing preconceptions about genre, skills, and expectations. Thematic analysis of data revealed a correlation between reduced self-consciousness and improved expression of observations and interaction when improvising, the latter supporting a view that positive self-constructs and creativity are linked. The second study used group improvisation alongside imaginative listening tasks as part of a developing composition curriculum. Characterful playing in improvisation, curiosity in listening, and a healthy dimension of perfectionism in composition were found to be connected by the attribute of risk-taking. Significant links emerged between behaviours in improvising, composing, and listening, indicating possible ways of indirectly nurturing creative autonomy and positive creative self-concept. This research informs a potential A-level composition curriculum that interweaves group improvising, listening, and composing. Rather than focussing on skills development, product assessment, or devising a model of the compositional process, this thesis recommends ways to nurture “unteachable” inner attributes such as intuition, self-trust, and aesthetic awareness, essential qualities in critical and autonomous composers.