Where Does Design Thinking Leave Design? Snapshots of a conversation with the design community

Spruce, Jonathan ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9173-4912, Kiernan, Louise and Douglas, Michelle (2020) Where Does Design Thinking Leave Design? Snapshots of a conversation with the design community. Iterations: Design Research & Practice Review (8). ISSN 2009-8243

Preview

Accepted Version Available under License In Copyright. Download (1MB) | Preview

Abstract

Design Thinking has gained recognition as an acclaimed process for generating innovative, human centred solutions at a social and business level. It has also gained notoriety amongst many designers, who claim that its success as an exported element of the design process has resulted in its commodification, and led to it becoming a diluted series of processes that lack criticality. This article describes the findings from a conversation session held at DRS2018 which posed the question: HAVE WE REACHED PEAK DESIGN THINKING? Participants were asked to identify with a range of positions on the topic and were then given three questions to provide a constructive debate. The findings point to a lack of a clear distinction between design and Design Thinking, a lack of consensus as to whether a designer is required in the process and also a lack of agreement as to its benefits. In order to prevent a continued backlash against Design Thinking the findings point to the need for a framework that can outline the clear distinction between design and Design Thinking, whether the designers skills are required and the context and scale of a project that would require design or Design Thinking or both.