‘Here be revisionary metaphysics!’ A critique of a concern about process philosophy

Giladi, Paul ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8934-3602 (2021) ‘Here be revisionary metaphysics!’ A critique of a concern about process philosophy. Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review, 60 (2). pp. 257-275. ISSN 0012-2173

Preview

Accepted Version Download (420kB) | Preview

Abstract

In this paper, I argue that John Dupré and Daniel Nicholson's ‘process manifesto’ is ironically more sympathetic to descriptive metaphysics than to revisionary metaphysics. Focusing on their argument that any process philosophy automatically slides into Whiteheadian obscurantism if it does not just rest content with revealing the problematic features of ordinary language, I argue that their position occludes a logical space, one in which revisionary metaphysics is articulated without any Whiteheadian obscurantism and involves no dereliction of critical/revisionary orientation. I argue that key features of the respective critical social ontologies of Judith Butler and Talia Mae Bettcher occupy such a logical space.